Player file
Peyton Manning
Quarterback · Caleboys · 2007–2015 · 8 seasons
Ring of Honor · No. 21 of fifty
Caleboys Ring of Honor, 3rd of five · All Cool Pete Team, Caleboys
109
Starts
2007–2015 · 8 seasons
2,572
Points
career
+254
PAR
career, every franchise
0
Titles
as a starter
21st
All-time
of 480 skill careers, career PAR
+18
Playoff PAR
career
Career PAR and franchise PAR are the same figure here: he only ever started for Caleboys.
Peyton Manning
QB · No. 18 · Caleboys
Career PAR
+254
On the roster in 2007, the first documented season.
No title in his eight starting seasons.
The record picks him up in 2007 with Caleboys; how he first arrived is not on file. He then stayed put for 8 seasons and 109 starts, all for Caleboys, which in a keeper league is the whole point of the format.
His best season was 2013: 461 points across 15 starts, +124.5 above replacement for Caleboys, the best quarterback in football that year. That is part of a career worth +253.5 PAR, 22nd in league history. He never started for a championship team.
The tail was not kind: 2015 came in at −39.7 across 6 starts. He finishes on 3rd in the Caleboys Ring of Honor and the Caleboys All Cool Pete Team at QB.
The career
One axis. Tenure above, the board below, PAR by season in the plot. Nine seasons on the axis, 2007 to 2015.
Replacement level
A hatched column labelled 0 STARTS is a season he was rostered and never started: nothing, not unknown. He was on a 2007 roster, before the first surviving draft board, so the band opens without a pick. One band: he only ever started for Caleboys.
Season by season
Franchise scope
| Season | Franchise | Starts | Points | NFL rank | Playoff PAR | PAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 | Caleboys | 15 | 342.3 | QB4 | +5.7 | +41.2 |
| 2008 | Caleboys | 14 | 285.1 | QB6 | +12.2 | +17.4 |
| 2009 | Caleboys | 15 | 353.2 | QB4 | −0.9 | +40.7 |
| 2010 | Caleboys | 15 | 349.1 | QB1 | +2.0 | +38.8 |
| 2012 | Caleboys | 14 | 323.2 | QB5 | −3.3 | +5.8 |
| 2013 | Caleboys | 15 | 460.9 | QB1 | +12.9 | +124.5 |
| 2014 | Caleboys | 15 | 368.5 | QB3 | −10.6 | +24.6 |
| 2015 | Caleboys | 6 | 90.0 | QB32 | — | −39.7 |
PAR is set against the season's replacement starter at the position, and the column shares one zero: ink to the right of it, halftone to the left. Franchise scope.
How he moved
2007
Founding
On the 2007 roster, before the first surviving draft board.
2007
Kept
On Caleboys’ roster every season since. Nine seasons, eight as a starter.